
Apparently my tweet upset some folks at Windstream. Let me explain: USTelecom has a forbearance petition at the FCC to eliminate UNEs. Windstream was originally on the side of the CLECs and INCOMPAS. Then Windstream made a private sweetheart deal with the ILECs and switched sides.
Windstream is an ILEC as well as a CLEC.
Why was the tweet supposedly inflammatory? Because I said “I’d be out for myself too if I had a tiny market cap, huge debt and lawsuits chasing me down.” Windstream is in financial straights. It has been for a long while. The spin off of the REIT CS&L (now called UNITI) was a stop gap measure to try to unburden from the debt. Windstream owes $5.8 Billion in debt. Revenue has been flat for more than a year.

Market cap as of today 9/17/2018: $215M
There are a number of lawsuits over the spin-off.
If I had flat revenue, huge debt, a tiny market cap and lawsuits chasing me, I would join the ILECs and take a deal for UNEs, too.
Many of my clients are CLECs. Currently I am interim executive director of an association of ISPs and CLECs. CLECs will get clobbered by this UNE forbearance. The fact that Windstream would make a side deal after opposing the petition, it is disheartening. Hence my tweet.
Is a strong Windstream good for the channel? Maybe. Personally, I have never sold any Windstream services. I sold some EarthLink but not Paetec or Broadview. I never understood the Windstream deal. How could they possibly be less in price on network than the company they were buying it from?!!
Let’s do the math on that. Even with a sweet wholesale deal at say 30% off retail, Windstream still has to pay commission on this which would erase about 25%. There is also the cost of delivering the service and billing it, which even if efficient would be around 15%. Under water.
Sure they get top line revenue but a loss. This is a stupid business model. I have seen it time and again.
Then someone at Windstream realizes that they are underwater too often a couple of years ago. The result is a decision to wipe out customers and channel partners to right size it.
I am not certain Windstream will ever be a strong channel vendor. Everything they do is about lowering prices. And no one sings their praises on service deliver so….? Where’s the value?
PS
If I have to hear how SD-WAN is growing, I am going to throw up. Two years ago SD-WAN sales were practically zero. So if now you have even $2 in SD-WAN sales, growth is up!!!







